Source authenticated

Depth of the in-tree of ss under q↦qsq−1q \mapsto q s q^{-1} on nn-cycles

Opus 4.8 constructed a branch of the stated depth, giving a lower bound, and believed it had a matching upper bound; that proof was wrong and the statement stayed a conjecture. FABLE 5 later proved it. In the author's summary of the method: "The proof turns conjugation, near ss, into base-pp arithmetic." A cycle near the fixed point splits into a coarse base permutation and a vector of carries in Z/p\mathbb{Z}/p, DD acts on the carries by the carrying of ordinary base-pp addition, and the depth comes out as the nilpotency length of a shift difference - exactly that for odd pp, one less for p=2p = 2. The single missing carry that odd primes absorb and 22 cannot is what produces the two-branch answer. A companion survey paper covers the rest of the graph: the other periodic orbits, congruences on basin sizes, and a cyclic-sieving count. The depth theorem is the substantive part.

Exact FrontierDelta

proved→proved

Scope and record

Occurred: Oct 29, 2026

Delta type: REGISTRY REVISION

Assumptions: VibeMathed verification: unreviewed. Publication: announcement. AI contribution: ai-discovered. VibeMathed editorial classifications, scores, notes, relations, and dataset structure are CC BY 4.0. Source statements and linked content retain their own rights.

Canonical aliases: Depth of the in-tree of $s$ under $q \mapsto q s q^{-1}$ on $n$-cycles · In-tree depth under cyclic conjugation

Confidence: Not scored

Registry verification: unreviewed · announcement · candidate

Open the source record ↗

Attribution

VibeMathed
registry · event recorded by

Claude FABLE 5
model · ai model contributor · Anthropic

Lineage and corrections

Corrects Depth of the in-tree of ss under q↦qsq−1q \mapsto q s q^{-1} on nn-cycles →

Supersedes Depth of the in-tree of ss under q↦qsq−1q \mapsto q s q^{-1} on nn-cycles →

Depth of the in-tree of ss under q↦qsq−1q \mapsto q s q^{-1} on nn-cycles parent of this event

Depth of the in-tree of ss under q↦qsq−1q \mapsto q s q^{-1} on nn-cycles evidence for this event

The depth theorem, with the full proof (companion paper, 24 July 2026) evidence for this event

The author's 2006 blog on the same question, via the Wayback Machine evidence for this event

The functional graph of the whole map (survey paper, 25 July 2026) evidence for this event

VibeMathed record: Depth of the in-tree of ss under q↦qsq−1q \mapsto q s q^{-1} on nn-cycles evidence for this event

This event attributed to Claude FABLE 5

Opus 4.8 constructed a branch of the stated depth, giving a lower bound, and believed it had a matching upper bound; that proof was wrong and the statement stayed a conjecture. FABLE 5 later proved it. In the author's summary of the method: "The proof turns conjugation, near ss, into base-pp arithmetic." A cycle near the fixed point splits into a coarse base permutation and a vector of carries in Z/p\mathbb{Z}/p, DD acts on the carries by the carrying of ordinary base-pp addition, and the depth comes out as the nilpotency length of a shift difference - exactly that for odd pp, one less for p=2p = 2. The single missing carry that odd primes absorb and 22 cannot is what produces the two-branch answer. A companion survey paper covers the rest of the graph: the other periodic orbits, congruences on basin sizes, and a cyclic-sieving count. The depth theorem is the substantive part. parent of this event

Act on this frontier

Verify, challenge, or extend the result.