Morley Simplices in Higher Dimensions: Regularity, Reflections, and Counterexamples

Source abstract

Trisecting the dihedral angles of an $n$-simplex defines its Morley simplex. We study the original simplices for which this simplex is regular. A criterion in terms of the Gram matrix of the facet normals reduces the problem to a matrix equation. The derivative of the Morley map at the regular simplex has two explicit eigenvalues, both nonzero for $n\ge3$; thus the regular simplex is an isolated solution. We conjecture that in dimensions four and five a regular Morley simplex forces two hyperplane reflections interchanging disjoint pairs of vertices. We prove that this conclusion fails in every dimension $6\le n\le200$ and in every dimension $n=\binom k2-1$ with $k\ge9$: in these dimensions there are simplices with regular Morley simplex and no hyperplane reflection symmetry. The examples for $8\le n\le200$ have dihedral symmetry of order $2(n+1)$, while the infinite family is based on the Johnson scheme. In dimension four we give exact constructions of two nonregular examples, defined by irreducible polynomials of degrees $18$ and $8$ with Galois groups $S_{18}$ and $S_8$. Neither example is expressible by radicals. The computer assisted existence proofs use exact rational arithmetic and intervals with outward rounding.