combinatorics / Euclidean Ramsey theory

Graham's spherical conjecture: every finite spherical set is Ramsey

Claims a seven-point cyclic set, for any transcendental radius parameter r>2r>2 (for example r=πr=\pi), that is not Ramsey: a finite colouring of Rn\mathbb R^n with no monochromatic congruent copy, in every dimension. Since the set lies on a circle, this disproves the conjecture that every spherical set is Ramsey. The colouring is non-constructive, built from a non-measurable derivation of R\mathbb R. The unverified appendix adds that almost every seven-point circular set is non-Ramsey and that the method cannot work below seven points. The OpenAI release's classification manuscript (23 September 2026) cites this paper as the disproof, adds a twelve-point spherical example by the same derivation-moment method, and proves every set of at most five circle points Ramsey; six circle points remain open between the two.

40Significance / 100
1Frontier events
0Verification tasks
0Recorded attempts

Temporal state

Current frontier

No reconciled state yet.

Append-only history

Frontier timeline

combinatoricsSep 20, 2026Significance 40/100Registry: unreviewed

Graham's spherical conjecture: every finite spherical set is Ramsey

Prior state unknown→disproved

Claims a seven-point cyclic set, for any transcendental radius parameter r>2r>2 (for example r=πr=\pi), that is not Ramsey: a finite colouring of Rn\mathbb R^n with no monochromatic congruent copy, in every dimension. Since the set lies on a circle, this disproves the conjecture that every spherical set is Ramsey. The colouring is non-constructive, built from a non-measurable derivation of R\mathbb R. The unverified…

SourceReplayReproducedFormal proofStatement auditExternal checkExpert reviewPeer review

Research memory

Claims and attempts

Scoped claims

Source authenticated

Claims a seven-point cyclic set, for any transcendental radius parameter r>2r>2 (for example r=πr=\pi), that is not Ramsey: a finite colouring of Rn\mathbb R^n with no monochromatic congruent copy, in every dimension. Since the set lies on a circle, this disproves the conjecture that every spherical set is Ramsey. The colouring is non-constructive, built from a non-measurable derivation of R\mathbb R. The unverified appendix adds that almost every seven-point circular set is non-Ramsey and that the method cannot work below seven points. The OpenAI release's classification manuscript (23 September 2026) cites this paper as the disproof, adds a twelve-point spherical example by the same derivation-moment method, and proves every set of at most five circle points Ramsey; six circle points remain open between the two.

Claims a seven-point cyclic set, for any transcendental radius parameter r>2r>2 (for example r=πr=\pi), that is not Ramsey: a finite colouring of Rn\mathbb R^n with no monochromatic congruent copy, in every dimension. Since the set lies on a circle, this disproves the conjecture that every spherical set is Ramsey. The colouring is non-constructive, built from a non-measurable derivation of R\mathbb R. The unverified appendix adds that almost every seven-point circular set is non-Ramsey and that the method cannot work below seven points. The OpenAI release's classification manuscript (23 September 2026) cites this paper as the disproof, adds a twelve-point spherical example by the same derivation-moment method, and proves every set of at most five circle points Ramsey; six circle points remain open between the two.

Recorded attempts

Evidence graph

Connected research record

Graham's spherical conjecture: every finite spherical set is Ramsey — Mathematical Frontier Network