geometry-topology / Algebraic geometry; singularities and derivation modules

The Lipman-Zariski conjecture in characteristic zero

Theorem 1.1: there are a finitely generated normal integral C\mathbb C-algebra AA of dimension two and a maximal ideal m\mathfrak m with DerC(A)≅A⊕2\mathrm{Der}_{\mathbb C}(A)\cong A^{\oplus2} and AmA_{\mathfrak m} not regular; the surface can be smooth away from that point. By Jorder's theorem no local tangent frame there commutes. The paper also answers negatively, in characteristic zero, the derivation-blowup question of Barajas, Chavez-Martinez and Romano-Velazquez (2026, Question 1). It does not address higher-dimensional non-isolated cases left open by earlier results or give a counterexample with a commuting frame (impossible by Jorder).

42Significance / 100
1Frontier events
0Verification tasks
0Recorded attempts

Temporal state

Current frontier

No reconciled state yet.

Append-only history

Frontier timeline

geometry-topologySep 23, 2026Significance 42/100Registry: unreviewed

The Lipman-Zariski conjecture in characteristic zero

Prior state unknown→disproved

Theorem 1.1: there are a finitely generated normal integral C\mathbb C-algebra AA of dimension two and a maximal ideal m\mathfrak m with DerC(A)≅A⊕2\mathrm{Der}_{\mathbb C}(A)\cong A^{\oplus2} and AmA_{\mathfrak m} not regular; the surface can be smooth away from that point. By Jorder's theorem no local tangent frame there commutes. The paper also answers negatively, in characteristic zero, the derivation-blowup question…

SourceReplayReproducedFormal proofStatement auditExternal checkExpert reviewPeer review

Research memory

Claims and attempts

Scoped claims

Source authenticated

Theorem 1.1: there are a finitely generated normal integral C\mathbb C-algebra AA of dimension two and a maximal ideal m\mathfrak m with DerC(A)≅A⊕2\mathrm{Der}_{\mathbb C}(A)\cong A^{\oplus2} and AmA_{\mathfrak m} not regular; the surface can be smooth away from that point. By Jorder's theorem no local tangent frame there commutes. The paper also answers negatively, in characteristic zero, the derivation-blowup question of Barajas, Chavez-Martinez and Romano-Velazquez (2026, Question 1). It does not address higher-dimensional non-isolated cases left open by earlier results or give a counterexample with a commuting frame (impossible by Jorder).

Theorem 1.1: there are a finitely generated normal integral C\mathbb C-algebra AA of dimension two and a maximal ideal m\mathfrak m with DerC(A)≅A⊕2\mathrm{Der}_{\mathbb C}(A)\cong A^{\oplus2} and AmA_{\mathfrak m} not regular; the surface can be smooth away from that point. By Jorder's theorem no local tangent frame there commutes. The paper also answers negatively, in characteristic zero, the derivation-blowup question of Barajas, Chavez-Martinez and Romano-Velazquez (2026, Question 1). It does not address higher-dimensional non-isolated cases left open by earlier results or give a counterexample with a commuting frame (impossible by Jorder).

Recorded attempts

Evidence graph

Connected research record