number-theory / Irrationality and algebraic degree

Nonquadraticity of Lambert series values and improved bounds for Erdős Problem 1049

For rational bases t=a/b>1t=a/b>1, F(t)=∑n≥1(tn−1)−1F(t)=\sum_{n\ge1}(t^n-1)^{-1} is irrational whenever log⁡b/log⁡a<0.5728\log b/\log a<0.5728, and a formalized refinement reaches 0.5732900.573290. The previous thresholds were 1/2−1/π2≈0.39871/2-1/\pi^2\approx0.3987 (Bundschuh and Väänänen, 1994) and 0.4056830.405683 (W. Cook, September 2026, self-published). Problem 1049 itself stays open: t=3/2t=3/2, with log⁡2/log⁡3≈0.631\log2/\log3\approx0.631, is still outside the region. Along the way, for every integer q≥2q\ge2 the numbers 1,F(q),F(q)21,F(q),F(q)^2 are linearly independent over Q\mathbb Q, so the Erdős-Borwein constant F(2)F(2) is not quadratic irrational. Both follow from one degree criterion for real algebraic bases: no relation of degree at most ee over Q(q)\mathbb Q(q) when eλlog⁡M(q)<log⁡qe\lambda\log M(q)<\log q, with λ=(42963+428220/π2)/202140≈0.42718\lambda=(42963+428220/\pi^2)/202140\approx0.42718.

12Significance / 100
1Frontier events
0Verification tasks
0Recorded attempts

Temporal state

Current frontier

No reconciled state yet.

Append-only history

Frontier timeline

number-theoryOct 7, 2026Significance 12/100Registry: lean checked

Nonquadraticity of Lambert series values and improved bounds for Erdős Problem 1049

Prior state unknown→proved

For rational bases t=a/b>1t=a/b>1, F(t)=∑n≥1(tn−1)−1F(t)=\sum_{n\ge1}(t^n-1)^{-1} is irrational whenever log⁡b/log⁡a<0.5728\log b/\log a<0.5728, and a formalized refinement reaches 0.5732900.573290. The previous thresholds were 1/2−1/π2≈0.39871/2-1/\pi^2\approx0.3987 (Bundschuh and Väänänen, 1994) and 0.4056830.405683 (W. Cook, September 2026, self-published). Problem 1049 itself stays open: t=3/2t=3/2, with log⁡2/log⁡3≈0.631\log2/\log3\approx0.631, is still outside the region. Along the way,…

SourceReplayReproducedFormal proofStatement auditExternal checkExpert reviewPeer review

Research memory

Claims and attempts

Scoped claims

Source authenticated

For rational bases t=a/b>1t=a/b>1, F(t)=∑n≥1(tn−1)−1F(t)=\sum_{n\ge1}(t^n-1)^{-1} is irrational whenever log⁡b/log⁡a<0.5728\log b/\log a<0.5728, and a formalized refinement reaches 0.5732900.573290. The previous thresholds were 1/2−1/π2≈0.39871/2-1/\pi^2\approx0.3987 (Bundschuh and Väänänen, 1994) and 0.4056830.405683 (W. Cook, September 2026, self-published). Problem 1049 itself stays open: t=3/2t=3/2, with log⁡2/log⁡3≈0.631\log2/\log3\approx0.631, is still outside the region. Along the way, for every integer q≥2q\ge2 the numbers 1,F(q),F(q)21,F(q),F(q)^2 are linearly independent over Q\mathbb Q, so the Erdős-Borwein constant F(2)F(2) is not quadratic irrational. Both follow from one degree criterion for real algebraic bases: no relation of degree at most ee over Q(q)\mathbb Q(q) when eλlog⁡M(q)<log⁡qe\lambda\log M(q)<\log q, with λ=(42963+428220/π2)/202140≈0.42718\lambda=(42963+428220/\pi^2)/202140\approx0.42718.

For rational bases t=a/b>1t=a/b>1, F(t)=∑n≥1(tn−1)−1F(t)=\sum_{n\ge1}(t^n-1)^{-1} is irrational whenever log⁡b/log⁡a<0.5728\log b/\log a<0.5728, and a formalized refinement reaches 0.5732900.573290. The previous thresholds were 1/2−1/π2≈0.39871/2-1/\pi^2\approx0.3987 (Bundschuh and Väänänen, 1994) and 0.4056830.405683 (W. Cook, September 2026, self-published). Problem 1049 itself stays open: t=3/2t=3/2, with log⁡2/log⁡3≈0.631\log2/\log3\approx0.631, is still outside the region. Along the way, for every integer q≥2q\ge2 the numbers 1,F(q),F(q)21,F(q),F(q)^2 are linearly independent over Q\mathbb Q, so the Erdős-Borwein constant F(2)F(2) is not quadratic irrational. Both follow from one degree criterion for real algebraic bases: no relation of degree at most ee over Q(q)\mathbb Q(q) when eλlog⁡M(q)<log⁡qe\lambda\log M(q)<\log q, with λ=(42963+428220/π2)/202140≈0.42718\lambda=(42963+428220/\pi^2)/202140\approx0.42718.

Recorded attempts

Evidence graph

Connected research record