combinatorics / Posets / hyperplane arrangements

Reading's Problem 9.3: Order Dimension Versus Rank for Simplicial Arrangements

Reading computed the order dimension of the poset of regions for most finite Coxeter arrangements, observed that an exceptional type whose dimension exceeds its rank would be the first known simplicial arrangement with that property, and recorded the general guess that every simplicial region poset has dimension equal to its rank (Problem 9.3 of his 2016 chapter); Segovia later asked the analogous question for oriented-poset lattices. False: the order dimension of the poset of regions can exceed the rank - the Coxeter arrangements $H_4$ and $E_6$ satisfy $\dim W(H_4) \ge 5$ and $\dim W(E_6) \ge 7$.

15Significance / 100
1Frontier events
0Verification tasks
0Recorded attempts

Temporal state

Current frontier

No reconciled state yet.

Append-only history

Frontier timeline

combinatoricsAug 14, 2026Significance 15/100Registry: unreviewed

Reading's Problem 9.3: Order Dimension Versus Rank for Simplicial Arrangements

Prior state unknowndisproved

Reading computed the order dimension of the poset of regions for most finite Coxeter arrangements, observed that an exceptional type whose dimension exceeds its rank would be the first known simplicial arrangement with that property, and recorded the general guess that every simplicial region poset has dimension equal to its rank (Problem 9.3 of his 2016 chapter); Segovia later asked the analogous question for ori…

SourceReplayReproducedFormal proofStatement auditExternal checkExpert reviewPeer review

Research memory

Claims and attempts

Scoped claims

Source authenticated

Reading computed the order dimension of the poset of regions for most finite Coxeter arrangements, observed that an exceptional type whose dimension exceeds its rank would be the first known simplicial arrangement with that property, and recorded the general guess that every simplicial region poset has dimension equal to its rank (Problem 9.3 of his 2016 chapter); Segovia later asked the analogous question for oriented-poset lattices. False: the order dimension of the poset of regions can exceed the rank - the Coxeter arrangements $H_4$ and $E_6$ satisfy $\dim W(H_4) \ge 5$ and $\dim W(E_6) \ge 7$.

Recorded attempts

Evidence graph

Connected research record

No public relationships recorded yet.

Reading's Problem 9.3: Order Dimension Versus Rank for Simplicial Arrangements — Mathematical Frontier Network