algebra / Geometric group theory; amenability

The amenability problem for Thompson's group F (Geoghegan's conjecture)

Theorem 1.1: Thompson's group FF is not amenable. The proof finds a fixed finite set S⊂FS\subset F and b>0b>0 with ∣hA△A∣≥b∣A∣|hA\triangle A|\ge b|A| for some h∈Sh\in S, for every nonempty finite A⊂FA\subset F, so no Folner sets exist. It converts approximate invariance of finite averages into an approximate fixed point of a Lipschitz self-map of a Hilbert ball, contradicting a Benyamini-Sternfeld displacement map that the paper constructs explicitly. It confirms Geoghegan's conjecture. The formal version gives no explicit expansion constant for a standard generating set, and the paper does not address other questions about FF such as its exact isoperimetric profile.

58Significance / 100
1Frontier events
0Verification tasks
0Recorded attempts

Temporal state

Current frontier

No reconciled state yet.

Append-only history

Frontier timeline

algebraSep 23, 2026Significance 58/100Registry: lean checked

The amenability problem for Thompson's group F (Geoghegan's conjecture)

Prior state unknown→proved

Theorem 1.1: Thompson's group FF is not amenable. The proof finds a fixed finite set S⊂FS\subset F and b>0b>0 with ∣hA△A∣≥b∣A∣|hA\triangle A|\ge b|A| for some h∈Sh\in S, for every nonempty finite A⊂FA\subset F, so no Folner sets exist. It converts approximate invariance of finite averages into an approximate fixed point of a Lipschitz self-map of a Hilbert ball, contradicting a Benyamini-Sternfeld displacement map that the pape…

SourceReplayReproducedFormal proofStatement auditExternal checkExpert reviewPeer review

Research memory

Claims and attempts

Scoped claims

Source authenticated

Theorem 1.1: Thompson's group FF is not amenable. The proof finds a fixed finite set S⊂FS\subset F and b>0b>0 with ∣hA△A∣≥b∣A∣|hA\triangle A|\ge b|A| for some h∈Sh\in S, for every nonempty finite A⊂FA\subset F, so no Folner sets exist. It converts approximate invariance of finite averages into an approximate fixed point of a Lipschitz self-map of a Hilbert ball, contradicting a Benyamini-Sternfeld displacement map that the paper constructs explicitly. It confirms Geoghegan's conjecture. The formal version gives no explicit expansion constant for a standard generating set, and the paper does not address other questions about FF such as its exact isoperimetric profile.

Theorem 1.1: Thompson's group FF is not amenable. The proof finds a fixed finite set S⊂FS\subset F and b>0b>0 with ∣hA△A∣≥b∣A∣|hA\triangle A|\ge b|A| for some h∈Sh\in S, for every nonempty finite A⊂FA\subset F, so no Folner sets exist. It converts approximate invariance of finite averages into an approximate fixed point of a Lipschitz self-map of a Hilbert ball, contradicting a Benyamini-Sternfeld displacement map that the paper constructs explicitly. It confirms Geoghegan's conjecture. The formal version gives no explicit expansion constant for a standard generating set, and the paper does not address other questions about FF such as its exact isoperimetric profile.

Recorded attempts

Evidence graph

Connected research record

The amenability problem for Thompson's group F (Geoghegan's conjecture) — Mathematical Frontier Network