theoretical-computer-science / Algebraic complexity; permanent versus determinant, geometric complexity theory

A cubic lower bound for the border determinantal complexity of the permanent (beyond the quadratic Mignon-Ressayre barrier)

Theorem 1.1: bdc(perm)≥cm3\mathrm{bdc}(\mathrm{per}_m)\ge cm^3 for m≥m0m\ge m_0, with c=1/(5529600e)c=1/(5529600e) and m0=1408m_0=1408, over C\mathbb C with arbitrary affine-linear entries and coefficientwise limits at fixed size; the same bound holds for dc\mathrm{dc}, and affine-linear algebraic branching programs for perm\mathrm{per}_m need Ω(m3)\Omega(m^3) vertices and edges (also in the border sense at fixed budget). The route is a smooth-hypersurface bound (r−1)(d−1)/(4e)(r-1)(d-1)/(4e) for forms of degree rr in dd variables, applied to a coefficient polynomial extracted from a permanent. It remains a fixed polynomial bound: superpolynomial dc\mathrm{dc} or bdc\mathrm{bdc} for the permanent, and VP versus VNP, stay open.

42Significance / 100
1Frontier events
0Verification tasks
0Recorded attempts

Temporal state

Current frontier

No reconciled state yet.

Append-only history

Frontier timeline

theoretical-computer-scienceSep 24, 2026Significance 42/100Registry: lean checked

A cubic lower bound for the border determinantal complexity of the permanent (beyond the quadratic Mignon-Ressayre barrier)

Prior state unknown→proved

Theorem 1.1: bdc(perm)≥cm3\mathrm{bdc}(\mathrm{per}_m)\ge cm^3 for m≥m0m\ge m_0, with c=1/(5529600e)c=1/(5529600e) and m0=1408m_0=1408, over C\mathbb C with arbitrary affine-linear entries and coefficientwise limits at fixed size; the same bound holds for dc\mathrm{dc}, and affine-linear algebraic branching programs for perm\mathrm{per}_m need Ω(m3)\Omega(m^3) vertices and edges (also in the border sense at fixed budget). The route is a smooth-hyper…

SourceReplayReproducedFormal proofStatement auditExternal checkExpert reviewPeer review

Research memory

Claims and attempts

Scoped claims

Source authenticated

Theorem 1.1: bdc(perm)≥cm3\mathrm{bdc}(\mathrm{per}_m)\ge cm^3 for m≥m0m\ge m_0, with c=1/(5529600e)c=1/(5529600e) and m0=1408m_0=1408, over C\mathbb C with arbitrary affine-linear entries and coefficientwise limits at fixed size; the same bound holds for dc\mathrm{dc}, and affine-linear algebraic branching programs for perm\mathrm{per}_m need Ω(m3)\Omega(m^3) vertices and edges (also in the border sense at fixed budget). The route is a smooth-hypersurface bound (r−1)(d−1)/(4e)(r-1)(d-1)/(4e) for forms of degree rr in dd variables, applied to a coefficient polynomial extracted from a permanent. It remains a fixed polynomial bound: superpolynomial dc\mathrm{dc} or bdc\mathrm{bdc} for the permanent, and VP versus VNP, stay open.

Theorem 1.1: bdc(perm)≥cm3\mathrm{bdc}(\mathrm{per}_m)\ge cm^3 for m≥m0m\ge m_0, with c=1/(5529600e)c=1/(5529600e) and m0=1408m_0=1408, over C\mathbb C with arbitrary affine-linear entries and coefficientwise limits at fixed size; the same bound holds for dc\mathrm{dc}, and affine-linear algebraic branching programs for perm\mathrm{per}_m need Ω(m3)\Omega(m^3) vertices and edges (also in the border sense at fixed budget). The route is a smooth-hypersurface bound (r−1)(d−1)/(4e)(r-1)(d-1)/(4e) for forms of degree rr in dd variables, applied to a coefficient polynomial extracted from a permanent. It remains a fixed polynomial bound: superpolynomial dc\mathrm{dc} or bdc\mathrm{bdc} for the permanent, and VP versus VNP, stay open.

Recorded attempts

Evidence graph

Connected research record

A cubic lower bound for the border determinantal complexity of the permanent (beyond the quadratic Mignon-Ressayre barrier) — Mathematical Frontier Network